Transformative Learning for Sustainability: Measuring What Matters

Geert Leemans

IMP>ACT is developing an assessment framework for ‘action competence’ within Sustainability and Climate Change Education (SCCE). In this blog post, we situate this assessment framework within the broader narrative of transformative learning for sustainability, and demonstrate how it fills a gap specifically in the area of monitoring and evaluation. 

Sustainable transitions as a ‘wicked problem’

Issues such as climate change, social injustice and biodiversity loss call for profound, systemic changes towards a more sustainable and just society. We usually refer to these as ‘transitions’. Such transitions are uncertain in their course and take a long time, but they also present us with a paradox: the ‘sense of urgency’ calls for decisive action, whilst the complexity of the problems leads to much controversy and feelings of powerlessness and uncertainty.

Problems of this kind lack clear boundaries, are systemic, context-dependent, contentious and have no straightforward solution. They are often referred to as ‘wicked’, and it is precisely because they are ‘wicked’ that they call for a transformative approach to climate and sustainability education. Through such a transformative learning process, people are empowered to gain a thorough understanding of a complex problem, to critically examine their own views, to experiment with different solutions and to take action. Transformative learning is therefore not just about knowledge, but also about what you do with that knowledge. That is why it is regarded by organisations such as UNESCO as essential for sustainable development and the SDGs.

Areas of tension

Typical ‘wicked problems’ are characterised by internal contradictions or ‘areas of tension’, which call into question the effectiveness of straightforward technical solutions.

A first area of tension concerns the level at which change must take place. The key question here is whether the emphasis should be placed primarily on people’s individual responsibility, or whether changes are needed primarily at the level of the broader socio-economic structures within which people live. Transformative learning seeks to bridge this tension by viewing both perspectives as mutually constitutive, within a continuous dynamic of continuity and change. When people think and act in their daily lives towards more sustainability and justice, the levers and obstacles they encounter become linked to the broader institutional reality in which they live, and the need for change can be revealed at a deeper, systemic level. 

A second area of tension lies between the urgency of the problems identified and the multitude of opinions regarding their nature and solutions. These debates are often existential in nature and are shaped by differing values, assumptions and visions of the future. Rather than attempting to reduce them to technical discussions – which is often what happens in reality – a transformative approach seeks to embrace this complexity and make the diversity of opinions part of a democratic and co-creative process. Because ‘wicked’ problems are ‘open-ended’ (and solutions are therefore not predetermined), learning, researching, experimenting and jointly implementing possible actions form an essential part of that co-creative process.

The need for a practice-oriented change model

Because educational interventions always take place within a context with which they interact, change is a process involving frequent feedback loops to earlier stages and to the broader context in which people learn and live. A robust ‘Theory of Change’ is therefore essential for the planning, implementation and evaluation of transformative ESD.

In such a ‘Theory of Change’, action-oriented ESD acts as a link in a transition process that a school, organisation or local community may undergo. The underlying logic boils down to the following five elementary steps:

  1. Learners develop a vision for a more sustainable future.
  2. They gain an understanding of how the broader context in which they live and learn perpetuates unsustainability, how they can intervene in it, and where they can find levers for change.
  3. They acquire various interrelated competencies, such as systems thinking, future thinking, cooperation or action competence. All transformative competencies are important, but action competence seems pivotal to actually set things in motion. 
  4. Teachers and educators use participatory, place-based, inquiry-oriented and action-oriented pedagogies to acquire these competencies.
  5. Problems, gaps and outcomes can be identified through evaluation and monitoring, aiming at improving educational practice.

Figure 1: Change model for transformative learning, adapted from Kioupi, V., & Voulvoulis, N. (2019). Education for Sustainable Development: A Systemic Framework for Connecting the SDGs to Educational Outcomes. Sustainability, 11(21), 6104. https://doi.org/10.3390/su11216104

Monitoring and evaluation: the role of IMP>ACT

Every step in our change model is essential. However, the fifth step is often the weak link. Whilst schools and organisations do focus on vision, competences and teaching methods, they often fail to identify exactly where the problems lie in terms of working in a truly action-oriented way, or what an action-oriented learning process has actually achieved. 

Research is increasingly highlighting the positive effects of transformative, action- oriented SCCE on knowledge and skills, commitment to values, confidence to take action, systems thinking and social learning. Many of these insights stem from small-scale practical studies, but quantitative evaluations, which survey large groups of pupils and teachers, are also being carried out more frequently.

Against this backdrop, the development of reliable measurement tools, such as those in IMP>ACT, is becoming increasingly important. This involves the iterative conceptualisation of measurement tools, screening of existing evaluation methods, empirical validation, and implementation in six case studies. By focusing on the conceptualisation and measurement of action competence and action-orientedness, IMP>ACT contributes significantly to step five of our change model. 

In conclusion

Transformative learning offers a pedagogical response to the ‘wicked problems’ that characterise sustainable transitions, not by avoiding areas of tension but, on the contrary, by fully recognising them as a lever for sustainable change.  A practice-oriented change model that links vision, context, competences, pedagogy and outcomes provides a framework for concrete transformative interventions. The IMP>ACT assessment framework is situated within the final, often overlooked step of that model: a scientifically underpinned tool for evaluating efforts towards transformative, action-oriented SCCE.

This blog post builds on an earlier literature review on transformative learning for ESD and GCE by Geert Leemans & Thomas Remerie (2026), drawing partly on the work of authors who are also involved in IMP>ACT. If you are interested in the original article, including references, click here.